The economic effects of land tenure patterns : comparative case studies of rural land and housing settlements projects in Wangnakaew, Nakhon Ratchasima province and Donyor, Nakhon Nayok province
Abstract:
This thesis compares the economic effects at the household level of two types of land tenure patterns: common and individual land tenure. The research question is whether and how different land tenure types create economic effects at the household level. The hypothesis is that households under the common land tenure system fare better economically than those under the individual land tenure system. This is because the common land tenure system leads to more community interactions and participation, making it easier for the government to support community initiatives, in turn creating the confidence among private investors, The unit of analysis in this study is the household. The independent variable is land tenure types, while the dependent variable is economic conditions. The indicators of the dependent variable include income, expenditure, debt, and occupational investment. The comparative case-study method is adopted. The two case studies are rural land and housing settlements projects in Wangnamkaew, Nakhon Ratchasima province and Donyor, Nakhon Nayok province. The empirical results indicate that the common land tenure system in Wangnamkaew creates mutual understanding among the community on land-use issues. The common land tenure systems in effect force people to participate in discussions to find common solutions to community matters. With the support from government agencies, the Wangnamekaew community is able to increase public participation in establishing community groups and enterprises. This in turn creates the incentives for the private sector to invest in the community or purchase products from the community, contributing to the increase in employment and improved economic conditions. By contrast, the individual land tenure system in Donyor creates ownership security, but the community members are more interested in developing their own land than in common land and community issues. Their household economic conditions after joining the project are not significantly different from before.